Lancaster Pie & Coffee

Gwenivere a month ago

Lovely place for meeting up with friends. It smells heavenly. Please make a few vegan hand pies or small pies! Vegans love pie, too. I come here with friends and can never partake. Please, I beg of you, vegan options.

Jason Sewell 3 months ago

Randomly walked in here for lunch today. Glad we did! Beef Pub Pie was amazing! Best I’ve had anywhere. Staff made me a latte, that blows away anything you’d get from one of those “fast food” coffee shops. I finished my lunch with a slice of apple pie. The all butter pie crusts are sweet, flaky, and taste amazing. Can’t wait to get back next time we’re in town.

Ronald 4 months ago

Stopped in this place by accident didn’t know much about it. My favorite pie and dessert in the world is cherry. So I wanted to check Out their tart cherry pie. I’ve been a chef for 20+ years. This is arguably the best piecrust I’ve ever had. Savory flaky and holds up well. You could put a shoe in this pie crust and it would be a 4.5. The filling was good, although I would’ve preferred just a slightly more jammy filling. There was a large piece of what I assume was gel or whatever thickner they use in the filling, that was very unpleasant. With the prices of everything being insane these days. $18 for a 6 inch pie still seems a bit steep, but I understand. I will definitely come there again and would recommend this to anyone who loves pie.

Ashley Dering 4 months ago

My husband and I stopped in this morning for coffee and some sweet treats to go. It was our first time there and I’m so glad we stopped in. The staff were so pleasant and welcoming! Coffee was delicious…I got an iced vanilla latte and my husband got a regular hot coffee. They were both so good! I also wanted to try the bananas and cream liege waffle and oh my…it’s absolutely delicious! My husband got a sour cherry hand pie and he loved it so much I didn’t get a picture of it in time! We can’t wait to come back and try some other pies!

Michael Clancy 4 months ago

Everything about this place from start to finish was absolutely fantastic. We stopped in for coffee and dessert, and both left completely thrilled. The coffee here is rich, dark, bold, and incredibly delicious. My red-eye, packed with two shots of espresso, delivered a perfect, robust kick, while my wife's americano with cream was remarkably smooth and deeply flavorful. Of course, the pies are next-level. Her rhubarb blackberry pie was amazing, and my peanut butter chocolate pie was easily the absolute best peanut butter pie I have ever had in my life. What makes this place even better is the atmosphere; while the space is tiny and only offers a few tables, the limited seating actually gives it a wonderfully cozy, intimate feel. The staff was incredibly interactive, funny, joyful, and kind. We both enjoyed our visit so much, highly recommend stopping by, and will definitely be back!